BMW M5 Forum and M6 Forums banner

Spark Plug replacement from dealer?

10K views 16 replies 11 participants last post by  Edmundogonc  
#1 ·
I took my 2010 E63 in under warranty for an Increased Emissions message and the dealer diagnosed it with a bad O2 sensor, which will be replaced under warranty.

But they also said they noticed a slightly rough idle and want me to consider replacing spark plugs. I haven't really noticed a rough idle at all personally. Dealer price is $795 to replace 10 spark plugs, is this too high?

I did some searching and it seems that these plugs from Amazon are identical to the BMW plugs: Amazon Link. Assuming I actually need new plugs, should I buy 10 of these and take them to an indy and just pay for labor? If yes, what's a reasonable cost of labor for this replacement?

Also - what happens if I don't replace the plugs at all? Could this lead to something catastrophic down the line? I only drive about 4000 miles a year.

PS - searching also showed that coil packs are easy to break while performing this replacement, I'll let the indy know about this to be careful if that's the route I end up taking.

Thanks in advance.
 
#2 ·
Dealer prices are always high so that # seems about right. For a Indy with around $100 an hour probably $300-400.

How many miles are on your car? I think 60k is a good time to change them out. Spark plugs are relatively cheap and take a beating in the combustion chamber. Nothing catastrophic unless one of the heads comes off (rare). Really just rough running.
 
#3 ·
Perfect, thanks so much. I currently have 50k miles and quite frankly I don't really notice a rough idle at all. I'll plan to replace them as soon as I notice any rough idling or running.

In case this helps anyone else in the future, my indy quoted 2.3 hours of labor to replace 10 spark plugs.
 
#4 ·
On a stock car, the plugs need changing every 37K miles, if modded, even less....
These plugs also serve as combustion monitoring for knock and misfire..
You can loose alot of response and power in general with old plugs on this motor..
 
#5 ·
I do mine every 10K miles...myself for $130 (10 plugs from Amazon).

The longer you let things wear, the more load it puts on other areas. As 5soko mentioned...plugs are used for more than just spark.

At least do it at the recommended intervals-otherwise pound foolish.
 
#8 ·
#11 ·
Use antiseize! And a bit of lube on the underside of the rubber on the coil packs to make them easier to remove next time.
 
#13 ·
I changed my sparkplugs at 35000 miles,,,it is in the manual recommened at 37000 miles

Thank you.
 
#16 ·
Spark plugs are very easy to change yourself with surprisingly few tools required. Certainly no need for special tools etc. The DIY you can find on here is spot on and very easy to follow. I did mine a week ago and it can be done by even an amateur mechanic in less than 2 hours. As i'm fairly competent with the spanners, I'd say its simple to do in under an hour. Only thing I would add is the part where he says about putting an extension or similar item through the ignition coil. That technique works well for the front 4 cylinders on each side, but due to the space restriction at the back, the best way is to put a socket over the small mounting point for the ignition coils cover and then use that as a pivot with the extension through the coil clip and it comes out very easy.
I changed mine at 82'000 miles. I did not know when they were changed before that and decided to do a full service on the engine just to be safe. By the looks of the plugs, it was not a minute too soon.
 

Attachments

  • Like
Reactions: horse86