[JustinM5]

Try again with clutch pedal down
Just a bit of tranny rattle I expect.

 

[hanbearpig]

Try again with clutch pedal down
Just a bit of tranny rattle I expect.

Thanks for the response!

If I don't hear the sound when cutting off the engine with the clutch pedal down (and is indeed a tranny rattle), should this be looked at? Does this mean something needs tightening?

 

[JustinM5]

Thrust bearing also called clutch release bearing, had this noise on many cars.
Not something I'd change unless wanted a new clutch - see what others say though :hihihi:

 

[hanbearpig]

Thrust bearing also called clutch release bearing, had this noise on many cars.
Not something I'd change unless wanted a new clutch - see what others say though :hihihi:

I tested after work and as you stated, with the clutch engaged, it didn't make the noise at cut off. So, nothing to worry about right? It doesn't mean the clutch or anything is going to fail soon?

Thanks in advance!

 

[manualshifter]

mine does that too- clutch rattle on shut down.

Look at it this way, the M5 was an extreme motorheads' car when it came out- a bespoke engine and all- if it was meant for little old ladies to go shopping in, they would have engineered out the clutch rattle- in this case those clever german engineers spent their time making it go faster for us nutters!

 

[hanbearpig]

mine does that too- clutch rattle on shut down.

Look at it this way, the M5 was an extreme motorheads' car when it came out- a bespoke engine and all- if it was meant for little old ladies to go shopping in, they would have engineered out the clutch rattle- in this case those clever german engineers spent their time making it go faster for us nutters!

So it's fairly normal and nothing to worry about or is it something that will need attention sometime down the line? I just don't want to overlook something that might turn into a bigger issue later.

Thanks!

 

[JustinM5]

Wouldn't pay it any mind.
Last clutch I fitted the new release bearing looked and felt like it would rattle, didn't fit like one on there, so left old one on.
No clutch expert by a long way though.
If you were listening for it prob hear it on many cars, M5 is heavy duty compared to run of mill cars too.

 

[hanbearpig]

Wouldn't pay it any mind.
Last clutch I fitted the new release bearing looked and felt like it would rattle, didn't fit like one on there, so left old one on.
No clutch expert by a long way though.
If you were listening for it prob hear it on many cars, M5 is heavy duty compared to run of mill cars too.

Coolio. Thanks for your input.

 

[UXB52]

Mine did it after new BMW clutch. I would go along with general view here and say it's normal.