BMW M5 Forum and M6 Forums banner
Cancel

Another Red Cog / Constant Chime question

1135 Views 23 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  flacoramos, 
Zirconocene
Hi all-

I'm looking for some help after a failed repair this weekend. What follows is the background, what's been done, some questions about how things work technically, and a request for advice on how to proceed. Here goes.

I performed a clutch and associated parts replacement due to some of the standard slipping, banging into drive symptoms that indicate a drivetrain issue.

The throwout bearing was just about completely stripped, which is what was likely the cause of the bad shifting/drive engagement. Here are the new parts I replaced:

  • New throwout bearing
  • New clutch fork
  • New clutch pivot thing (plastic, OEM BMW part)
  • Refurbished clutch: sent the old one out to Kentucky Clutch and had them install Kevlar friction material

Work I did while the transmission was out:

  • I swapped the bolts from the slave cylinder into the transmission as some insurance for later.
  • I inspected the slave cylinder but didn't see any signs of leaking so it was not replaced.
  • I replaced all the o rings on the solenoids
  • I unpinned and resealed all the wires to the sensor strip, as they were cracking and copper was exposed

When I went to start the adaptation, it never completed and I ended up with a red cog and a constant chime. I was able to drive that way without any performance issue and the new clutch and components gave me fast, smooth shifts (after breaking in the new clutch gently).

It seemed like I needed to revisit the components that I thought were OK. As such, I recently did the following work:

- Rebuilt the slave cylinder (new seals, kit from SMG Society MLR)

After many, many rounds of bleeding the system, the adaptation failed again, so I moved on to the last component that I thought might be the issue:

- Replaced the PLCD sensor/harness

Again, the adaptation failed in INPA. I tried to use DIS, as well, but that did not work. I've never been able to understand how to use ISTA, so I was not able to try the adaptation with that software.

Here's the technical questions:

  • Besides the seals in the slave cylinder, what else could wear out? The other important thing in there is the magnet ring that slides along the rod does that wear out? It is possible that it has slid out of position somehow?
  • Is there any other way to test the PLCD itself? I'm not sure, now, that my old PLCD was faulty.
  • The error seems to be that the zero point of the clutch position is out of range. Would this be caused by a lower general thickness of the friction material (which is what I observed with the Kevlar clutch material, as compared with the standard/remaining organic clutch material)

What's my next step?
Can I somehow trick the software into thinking that the clutch engagement point is in range, somehow?
Is it possible this is a result of my "fix" of the sensor strip wires?

Let me just say, the car has been driving great, just driving me crazy with the incessant chime.

Thanks
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
1 - 20 of 24 Posts
F
In before @platii :ROFLMAO:

Zirconocene said:
  • The error seems to be that the zero point of the clutch position is out of range. Would this be caused by a lower general thickness of the friction material (which is what I observed with the Kevlar clutch material, as compared with the standard/remaining organic clutch material)
Click to expand...
Very likely. Note clamping force will be decreased with thinner material.

Zirconocene said:
Can I somehow trick the software into thinking that the clutch engagement point is in range, somehow?
Click to expand...
Not the software. But guess you could try adding shims between slave and trans and/or between PLCD and slave. Not sure whether it'll work or if it's worth the effort tho... Up to you to decide.

Zirconocene said:
Is it possible this is a result of my "fix" of the sensor strip wires?
Click to expand...
Unlikely.
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
@flacoramos : That's a bummer, if I need to buy a new clutch disc, but it was always going to be a bit of an experiment with the Kevlar material. I didn't realize that it would be so much thinner than standard. I'll start pricing things out.

Cheers
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
OK, after some discussion with local car folks, some more questions.

  • When the slave cylinder is not engaged, meaning when the clutch is against the pressure plate, is the rod in the slave cylinder compressed, or extended? Just as a thought experiment, which way would one want to change the slave cylinder rod to compensate for the thinner clutch material: shorten it, or extend it?
  • If the idea about the thinner clutch material is correct, it implies that what the car is reading is a clutch disk that is too worn. Is that right?
  • What is the minimum clutch thickness for the car? Meaning, if I can figure out what the thickness was of the material that was used to refurbish the clutch disk I can sort of verify this whole idea of that as the root cause.
  • Finally, is it the PLCD that ultimately tells the car whether the clutch disk is too thin and is what is reporting the clutch zero point out of tolerance?

Many thanks
Reply
Save
Like
P
First before saying anything drive the car more then try to adapt the system, this will help get rid of the air bubbles still trapped.
Did the clutch slave AND shift block bleeding PASSED?.

Give my brain something to chew on, like fault codes adaptation routine fail messages which is displayed after an adaptation step failure.
Which adaptation steps failed?.
Short video viewing INPA>Analog 3 status page starting with just ignition ON, depress the brake and release, start up the car, select first gear, start to move the car slowly till the clutch disengage. Print screen the adaptation values stored in INPA SMG>Status>SHIFT+F2.
Zirconocene said:
Besides the seals in the slave cylinder, what else could wear out?
Click to expand...
The cylinder wall.
Zirconocene said:
Is there any other way to test the PLCD itself? I'm not sure, now, that my old PLCD was faulty.
Click to expand...
It is fine if it doesn't give negative value.
Zirconocene said:
The error seems to be that the zero point of the clutch position is out of range. Would this be caused by a lower general thickness of the friction material (which is what I observed with the Kevlar clutch material, as compared with the standard/remaining organic clutch material)
Click to expand...
Possible.
Zirconocene said:
Is it possible this is a result of my "fix" of the sensor strip wires?
Click to expand...
No since no fault codes for gears position.
Zirconocene said:
I didn't realize that it would be so much thinner than standard.
Click to expand...
How thick it is?.
Zirconocene said:
What is the minimum clutch thickness for the car?
Click to expand...
Average is 5-6mm.
Zirconocene said:
When the slave cylinder is not engaged, meaning when the clutch is against the pressure plate, is the rod in the slave cylinder compressed, or extended?
Click to expand...
is not engaged=compressed.
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
Hi @platii , I was hoping you'd jump in.

I actually drove the car for about a year, over 5000 miles, with this issue, and it never went away. I kept hoping that it was air that needed to make its way through the system but that never seemed to work out.

The car is currently not driveable, as the driveshaft is disconnected and the exhaust is not attached (not that I couldn't drive the car without the exhaust, but I'm sure my neighbors would hate me for it).

I have a new error currently, I think as a result of my messing around in DIS, where the pump won't build pressure, or activate when I open the door. I believe that I need to clear the current errors then start the adaptation again to get the SMG to a place where I can get you the errors that come up. Currently, the error is 4F67. Prior to this round of work, the error was always something like "...(something) out of tolerance", aber in Deutsch.

I don't remember the thickness of the Kevlar material, just being very surprised at how thin it is. I am resolved to replace the clutch, again, and can measure everything once I get the old clutch disk out. This time, it's getting a proper Sachs disk.

For the 5-6 mm that you talk about for thickness, is that the total thickness of the plate? Assuming equal wear, what does that mean for the friction material? Or is that the minimum thickness of the friction material?

As always, many thanks
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
dbenkert
Would be nice if you could find clutch open and clutch close PLCD values to compare to other board members. I'm running a single-disk Clutchmasters setup with single mass flywheel and absolutely no errors, so there is room so long as the system can adapt to the 3 necessary points (open, slip, closed). Do you have INPA? With that you can read all sensor values real-time which becomes critical (in my experience) in properly diagnosing these systems.
Reply
Save
Like
  • Like
Reactions: 1
P
Zirconocene said:
is that the total thickness of the plate?
Click to expand...
Yes the total plate thickness, about 2.5mm on each friction side.

Was this kevlar clutch used since a year ago?.
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
@dbenkert : I should be able to pull those numbers; they're in the Digital and Analog Values part of INPA, right?

Here are the numbers I have from the last adaptation attempt, before I messed things up with DIS.

Zero current clutch value: 1050.0
Clutch engagement position: 650.0
Clutch bearing control adaptation value P0: 50
Clutch bearing control adaptation value P2: 100
Zero point of clutch position: (!) 111
Valve cover clutch: 20.0
Auskuppelstelllung: (!) 100.0
Clutch bearing control adaptation value P1: 80
Clutch bearing control adaptation value P3: 100

I don't know if that helps; I can try to get those numbers if I've given you a nonsense response.

Thanks
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
platii said:
Yes the total plate thickness, about 2.5mm on each friction side.

Was this kevlar clutch used since a year ago?.
Click to expand...
Correct, this is the clutch I have been using for the past year. The driveability was great, but it was after some really terrible times with the degraded release bearing, so everything seemed like a huge improvement.

Cheers
Reply
Save
Like
F
platii said:
Yes the total plate thickness, about 2.5mm on each friction side.

Was this kevlar clutch used since a year ago?.
Click to expand...
Curious where did you get those numbers? I saw newtis only gives a measurement limit to rivets, so not very useful.

As an FYI newtis shows BMW uses a clutch wear-measurement tool on other cars, not for SMGs tho.

I still have my old smg clutch but with recent snow not in the mood to pull it out.
Reply
Save
Like
P
Flaco, just old used clutch disk measurement.
Reply
Save
Like
P
The majority of those adaptation value are the factory sitting and doesn't help much. Show the values from Status>Analog 3 for the PLCD and clutch valve position.
Reply
Save
Like
Alan Arnesen
I have a new SMG clutch and pressure plate I could measure tomorrow? It's up for grabs if you need one but I still have an SMG car so I'm not giving it away.

Never heard of an overhauled clutch and pressure plate. There are two clutch disks BTY.
Reply
Save
Like
dbenkert
4
Alright, I went out and measured the factory-original clutch I had sitting in the garage. Be mindful this unit has 106k (amazing) but wasn't slipping or fully-failed. Second screenshots are my current adaptions read from INPA, albeit this is with a single-disk clutch masters clutch/flywheel setup so can't be directly compared to dual-clutch OE:

Camera accessory Automotive tire Bicycle part Cameras & optics Font


Automotive tire Camera accessory Bicycle part Rim Bicycle accessory


Rectangle Font Parallel Number Screenshot


Rectangle Font Parallel Terrestrial plant Screenshot
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
  • Like
Reactions: 2
P
Nothing out of the ordinary for the above values. The last image info is default, no use. The ones at the end (not showed) has the gears shift point.
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
Here is a picture I took of the Analog 3 values, which is what I think was requested.

Computer Personal computer Font Gadget Display device


The car currently has a 4f67 error and the pump won't prime, so I'm hoping that disconnecting the battery will help clear that and I can get any other information folks might need to help me out.

If this isn't the right screen, please let me know and I'll get the right one.

Thanks
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
P
Zirconocene said:
Here is a picture I took of the Analog 3 values, which is what I think was requested.
Click to expand...
There is more requested; depress brake to extend the slave.
Reply
Save
Like
Alan Arnesen
Disconnecting the battery will do nothing. Clear the codes with INPA and then manually active the pump and watch/time the pressure cycle.
Reply
Save
Like
Zirconocene
@Alan Arnesen : I thought I knew how to activate the pump in INPA, but I can't seem to find it. Can you help a brother out?

@platii : I'll see what I can do to get that data. I went ahead and ordered a new clutch disc, so I'm a little on the fence about just trying to pull the transmission today, to be ready to install the new clutch next weekend. I have other projects that are acting up, so it might be a bit of a decision.

Thanks all, I really appreciate the help. I love this car, and I love this transmission, but I definitely don't love working on this transmission!

Cheers
Reply
Save
Like
1 - 20 of 24 Posts
BMW M5 Forum and M6 Forums
M5Board is the best forum community for information on the BMW M5 E60 (V-10), E39 (V-8), E34 (straight 6), E28, F90 and F10. Discuss performance, specs, reviews and more!
Full Forum Listing
Explore Our Forums
E39 M5 and E52 Z8 Discussion E60 M5 and E61 M5 Touring Discussion Parts / Other For Sale or Wanted E63/E64 M6 Discussion E34 M5 Discussion
Top