Buh Bye BMW? 2008 M5 Order Canceled. [Safety concerns after IIHS test results] - Page 16 - BMW M5 Forum and M6 Forums

Go Back   BMW M5 Forum and M6 Forums > General Forums > Off Topic Forum

Off Topic Forum This is the place for mature discussions not necessarily related to cars. This is however also moderated and only registered members are allowed to post. No religion and no vicious attacks.


Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
Old 23rd August 2007, 13:31   #151
Barry Lausch
M5 Guru (>2000 posts)
 
Barry Lausch's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Moving Target

Garage: 2008 E60 M5 Sepang Bronze

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 339
Thanked 257 Times in 179 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by M500 AED View Post
Wayward - As usual both entertaining and enlightening.

No I will not even think of selling my M5.

Safety is important to me but it comes second to the sensuous pleasure of driving an M5 and riding a superbike.

Neither is really really safe but IMHO on balance both are still worth doing.
+1, and UFH I've tried it................. save your time and gas.
__________________
2008 E60 ///M5 Sepang/Sepang/Walnut

Last edited by Barry Lausch; 23rd August 2007 at 13:36.
Barry Lausch is offline  
Old 23rd August 2007, 15:36   #152
TopEnd
M5 Guru (>2000 posts)
 
TopEnd's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: County of KINGS, New York
Age: 28

Garage: 2007 E63 ///M6

Sales Feedback: (2)

Thanks: 294
Thanked 78 Times in 65 Posts
For the record I will never turn to any manufacturer but BMW. I'm 21 and I had an E36 318i when I was 16. I've owned 95 purple m3 coupe, 98 m3 4door sedan, 97 540i 6spd, an E53 x5. I come from a strong family of BMW owners, and am honestly not allowed to drive anything else. I am (for the short time span) somewhat experienced with BMWs. What I do know is that I almost lost my brother in a fatal e36 328is accident. I was surprised to see him walk away with scratches (which really convinced me). If you guys have really read my posts, all I am saying is that I have faith in BMW resolving this issue. Now that I have a daughter certain features do become more important than some. I will not leave BMW. Just disappointed.

Let me give 2 situations. (Just trying to let the crew see my point of view)
  • Crossing through an intersection, when an idiot decides to take the light blazing 70 and smacks the passenger side. Your E60 gets canned, total write off. Everyone lives (kids, friends, and wife). Everyone brags about BMW safety. Insurance cuts a check, and you hop into another E60 M5. Life is good!
  • Crossing through an intersection, when an idiot decides to take the light blazing 70 and smacks the passenger side. Your E60 gets canned, total write off. Wife and kids die your friend is now brain damaged and paralyzed from the waist down. (This is where I get confused at) Insurance cuts a check and you hop into another E60 M5.

What does one say about the safety of BMW after this? Which one would you prefer after a fatal accident, situation 1 or 2? Or do we still factor in performance and drive more aware next time? Can “All the money in the world buy” back your family???

Please respond on this!!
TopEnd is online now  
Old 23rd August 2007, 19:19   #153
M5boy
Member, P500 Sport, DSC On (>700)
 
M5boy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: OC

Garage: 08 Alpine White M6

Sales Feedback: (4)

Thanks: 74
Thanked 58 Times in 35 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by TopEnd View Post
For the record....
Simple as that at the end of the day. Nice post.

And for the record for people saying there are many other things that can happen to you to end your life other than car accidents. That is a probability game i would not want to play with the rest of my family in the car. Aside from serious diseases and health conditions, automotive accidents are the largest killer of people in this country. We dont always have control over a situation like a car accident, so why not prepare yourself to a good level(that bmw has been known for). Of course there is the balancing act of the many pluses and minuses of the car, but traditionally, was safety something people had to weigh out on a bmw?(On retrospect that was a bad idea, no matter the make, but is it wrong to give bmw credit in the safety department?) It sure wasnt when we bought any of our bmw's, and thats the point. We had a 01 e38 740il and it got hit(from the back) at a rolling crawl speed by another car going roughly 50 miles per hour according to the police report. My brother, his wife and my mom were all in the car and they walked out with sore necks. The other car's engine needed a separate tow truck. The car was brand new and it had a decent amount of sub-frame damage, came out to roughly 23k in repairs. We didnt look up the safety ratings of that car before we bought it, but had some faith in bmw, and why shouldnt we have? When i company you trust your family's life with gives you a reason to question them, it is as TopEnd said, disappointing. Bmw needs to fix this even if some of its customers dont care about it. Its likely not good enough for bmw to say that its drivers are of a different breed, and wont be discouraged by simply safety results...At least for brand image,lol.

Initially i thought the seating position was very odd in the test car, which i still believe. However, as another poster pointed out, other cars have the same seating position. So in a sense, all things being equal the e60 performed worse than its same class competitors. Or, short and oddly shaped people shouldnt drive e60's?

Maybe you feel its your time to go when god decides. But when i have a family of my own, rest assured ill do anything short of sitting god right back down in his chair before he "decides" its time for my family to go. I doubt by that time bmw will have problems like this; i have faith that they will do their due diligence in the matter.

Sorry if that came out as a rant...

Edit: in case anyone is wondering about how many bmw's me and my family have had experience with, heres the list.

00' 540i, 01' X5 4.4, 01' 740il, 03' m5 ,04' x5 4.4, 04' 330cic, 07' 750li
__________________
Arjun
Fight ON!

08 Alpine White M6 SMG - Loaded, some mods...
06 VW Touareg V10 TDI + Powerchip: 360hp, 630lb-ft
03 M5(Sold)
00 540(Sold)

Last edited by M5boy; 23rd August 2007 at 19:26.
M5boy is offline  
Old 24th August 2007, 01:47   #154
Simple1
Member, Sport: On DSC: On (>100 posts)
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: NYC

Garage: None

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 56
Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
just another heads up see all the other cars and how bmw performed in the actual videos

http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/c...htestvideo.htm
Simple1 is offline  
Old 24th August 2007, 17:03   #155
Claus
Member, Sport: On DSC: On (>100 posts)
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Leverkusen, Germany

Garage: BMW 750i Black, BMW M6 (E24) White

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 11
Thanked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by KIP View Post
Sorry, but by todays standads 4 stars is a really bad result and the 4 stars came after a recrash. The first 5-series NCAP result was 3 stars, which is HORRIBLE! All other major cars manufacturers get five stars easily (even a Toyota Yaris got 5 stars!).

http://www.newswheel.com/newswheel/s...eral-final.htm
@KIP

1st) You can't compare a Toyota Yaris with a 5 series BMW – this are two different vehicle classes. Translated: This Toyota is NOT so safe like the BMW! Small cars have other demands on safety.

2nd) Look here the ADAC test results (based on Euro NCAP):

http://www.adac.de/Tests/Crash_Tests/Automodelle/BMW_5_2004.asp?ComponentID=101246&SourcePageID=8650

The 5 series got here 16 of 18 possible points in a side impact crash.

3rd) 4 stars or 5 stars: BMW has a poor pedestrian protection. For this reason it will not get 5 stars. Pedestrians are usually not in the car.

4th) Look here a REAL LIFE TEST which says more than the IIHS with a dummy in a very "deplaced" position:

http://www.m5board.com/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=102154

But OK, BMW has to do something to pass the IIHS test also in the near future. In every case the 5 series per today is NOT UNSAFE!

And for all the people who are worried about their children: This car is very safe in the rear passenger font!

NB: This is my 1st post on this board but I'm a reader for a long time.

Claus

Last edited by Claus; 24th August 2007 at 17:07.
Claus is offline  
Old 24th August 2007, 18:06   #156
JoeClothing
Member, P500 Sport, MDM on (>800)
 
JoeClothing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Bethesda Maryland

Garage: M5 Sepang Bronze/Sepang

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 7
Thanked 7 Times in 6 Posts
Will the real Saint Nick please stand up! J/K

Welcome Claus Nice 1st. post. I have to ask though, who is the original....you or Unfoundhorsepower?
JoeClothing is offline  
Old 24th August 2007, 18:26   #157
Claus
Member, Sport: On DSC: On (>100 posts)
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Leverkusen, Germany

Garage: BMW 750i Black, BMW M6 (E24) White

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 11
Thanked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeClothing View Post
Welcome Claus Nice 1st. post. I have to ask though, who is the original....you or Unfoundhorsepower?
Oha, I forgot that "Santa Claus" is the man with "Unfoundhorsepower" ( ) in the English speaking areas!

"Claus" (or "Klaus") is a common surname in Germany with no direct relation to the "four-legs-horsepower-man". On the other hand it's an abbreviation from "Nikolaus" (we celebrate it on Dec. 6) and the small brother from the "Weihnachtsmann" (in English also Santa Claus - we celebrate it on Dec. 24). In English both men are the same, I assume.

Claus (distance to "Nürburgring" only approx. 60 miles )
Claus is offline  
Old 24th August 2007, 19:28   #158
JoeClothing
Member, P500 Sport, MDM on (>800)
 
JoeClothing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Bethesda Maryland

Garage: M5 Sepang Bronze/Sepang

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 7
Thanked 7 Times in 6 Posts

Ah yes...the feast of St. Nicholas. I am half German and we use to celebrate this holiday as well as Christmas. Nothing wrong with a kid getting a few extra presents IMO.
Enjoy the board,
Joe
JoeClothing is offline  
Old 24th August 2007, 19:50   #159
Claus
Member, Sport: On DSC: On (>100 posts)
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Leverkusen, Germany

Garage: BMW 750i Black, BMW M6 (E24) White

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 11
Thanked 10 Times in 8 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeClothing View Post
Ah yes...the feast of St. Nicholas. I am half German and we use to celebrate this holiday as well as Christmas. Nothing wrong with a kid getting a few extra presents IMO.
Enjoy the board,
Joe
St. Nicholas is very funny for the kids here. We hang up empty sockets on door handles over night and it will fill then with sweets. But OK, we are a little bit OT now

Claus
Claus is offline  
Old 25th August 2007, 20:02   #160
Richard in NC
M5 Guru (>2000 posts)
 
Richard in NC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: Charlotte, NC
Age: 54

Garage: 2008 BMW 550i

Sales Feedback: (0)

Thanks: 2
Thanked 54 Times in 40 Posts
Wow! I had some catching up to do on this thread since I've been away for a week and thought I'd throw in my 2 cents.

First some background. I've bought 4 BMWs since '98 and nothing else. Why? Because I HAD researched safety and felt that BMW provided excellent safety along with the performance and luxury. All of the crash test data and "I walked away" stories of the E39 validated the safety aspect of my purchase decisions of the 540i and 2002 M5.

I was concerned when BMW switched to aluminum front ends on the E60 & E63. Frontal crash test results alleviated my fears and allowed me to feel good with the 650i purchase. I only hope I don't get into a minor accident that requires a complete front rebuild

I had noticed the poor rear crash test result of the E60. When reading the details, it seems the IIHS puts the headrest in the lowest most rearward position. They say its because Americans are dumb and don't properly adjust headrests. Thats why BMW gets a poor result with the headrest geometry alone and why comfort seats do better, and why any car with a super tall fixed headrest (eg Volvo) does well in the test.

I for one DID have a rear impact crash in the E39 M5. It wasn't hit that hard but I suffered absolutely NO issues from receiving a pretty solid THUMP from behind.

The EUROCAP poor pedestrian result is because the low front of the E60 bounces them over the hood instead of knocking them down and running over them. Is that really better?

So that brings us to the present and the release of the IIHS side impact test. It happens to coincide with me looking to purchase an '08 550 or M5. Here are my thoughts.
1. I am suprised and concerned with the result.
2. I am more suprised and concerned with BMWs initial comments of "we aren't concerned, it was one test on one day"
3. BMW ought to be concerned. This will KILL their whole reputation, not just 5er sales. I hope and suspect they will do a redesign of something (maybe a larger side airbag) and ask for a retest.
4. It is intersting timing with HaroldC's horrendous side impact accident that he is recovering from. I would say the E60 seems pretty solid and safe from that example.
5. I do agree that the seating position was odd in the IIHS test, that the 5er seemed to stay stationary and take a larger impact than the others, etc. I can't explain this, maybe Kia paid IIHS to tie down the BMW to make it fare worse. However, bottom line? I am glad I'm 6 ft tall and sit further back but since accidents and people sizes are random, BMW should design the car to deal with any size driver, any side impact situation, and not have significant issues with certain positions (assuming they are proper for a given sized driver), etc.
6. All of that being said, I'd still feel MUCH safer in a BMW than a KIA in ANY accident situation. Besides, the way they drive sucks compared to a BMW and I wouldn't own one anyways.

This situation will not steer me away from BMW but it does require pause for thought to see what BMW does. So far, it looks like they hope it was just go away and be forgotten..

PS: MJ, I understand your concern but I don't consider the one IIHS test to be a deal breaker at this time.
__________________
Richard
NEW 2008 550i Space Gray, Creme Biege/Black/Dk Poplar : Sport Package, Cold Weather, Sport Auto, Nav, HUD, CA, Logic 7, iPod/USB, SAT, HD Radio, Lane departure warning
'06 X3 Black Sapphire/Tan PP, Steptronic, Xexons, Heated seats, Privacy glass, UGDO, Compass, bike rack, iPod adapter
Sold '06 650i Black Sapphire/Cream Beige sport package, 6 speed
'02 M5 Titanium Silver/Black Luxury/Burl

Last edited by Richard in NC; 25th August 2007 at 20:07.
Richard in NC is offline  
Closed Thread

Bookmarks



Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
List: Sultan of Brunei's complete car collection, no M5 but an Alpina Gustav ALPINABoard.com | BMW Alpina Discussion 109 14th September 2007 18:16
Complete BMW M6 Convertible Press Release in English and German (Short Version) Gustav E63 BMW M6 Forum and BMW M6 Convertible | m6board.com 7 23rd June 2006 04:27
BMW M Manager Bruhnke at Stockholm Open, Sweden and answer to your questions Gustav E60 M5 and E61 M5 Touring Discussion 53 12th May 2005 01:51
BMW M Manager Bruhnke at Stockholm Open, Sweden and answer to your questions Gustav E63 BMW M6 Forum and BMW M6 Convertible | m6board.com 51 25th March 2005 17:14
BMW M Manager Bruhnke at Stockholm Open, Sweden and answer to your questions Gustav E39 M5 and E52 Z8 Discussion 11 30th October 2004 14:36

Loading...

All times are GMT +2. The time now is 08:42.



Everything Copyright 2000-2008. Do not use ANYTHING from this site without written permission. All images, graphics, sound files, video files and text appearing on this web site are the exclusive property of m5board.com and are protected under international copyright laws. All images, graphics, sound files, video files and text on this site are for on-screen and on-site viewing and listening only. No part of this web site may be reproduced, copied, saved, stored, manipulated, or used in any form for personal or commercial purposes without the prior written permission of m5board.com. Use of any image or graphic as the basis for another photographic concept or illustration is a violation of the copyright. Any copyright infringement will be prosecuted to the full extent of federal and international copyright laws. M5board.com is an enthusiast board and we don't condone any dangerous activity. Our airfield events are completely safe based on years of experience, we conduct them during clear visibility with mature participants that have several years of experience with high-performance automobiles, large unobstructed run-off zones on sealed off private former military airbases and we clearly mark the braking zones. If inexperienced with high speed driving we do not recommend organizing your own event but attending a high-performance driving school. The use of the term "BMW" on this site is for reference only, and does not imply any connection between m5board.com and BMW AG or BMW North America.