Another review from MSN homepage

[tonach]

First drive: New BMW M5
by Brian Laban, last updated September 14 2004

For twenty years since the first example appeared as a new breed of super-fast premium saloon, BMW have thought of the mighty M5 as their ‘businessman’s express’ – the up-market and practical face of high performance driving. And one of the things that always made the M5 particularly attractive to a certain kind of customer was that, for all its performance, it was relatively understated, and relatively uncomplicated – just plenty of power in a thoroughly developed but straightforward rear-drive chassis wrapped in a muscular, but really quite subtle, body.


The new, fourth generation M5 is still, unmistakably, the businessman’s express, but now it has a new edge, and a bit less of the old understatement. Because the new M5 is more aggressive than ever. Having been revealed in what turns out to be very close to production form at the Geneva Show in March this year, as the Concept M5, the real thing goes on sale in most of Europe in January, and in the UK a couple of months later ‘in Spring’, with a projected price of £61,755.

It will be a lot of fast, handsome car for the money, and in some ways a much more complex one than the M5 has ever been before – which is partly good news and partly less good news, depending on how subtly you like your ‘businessman’s express’ performance to be delivered.

Engine: Mind-boggling
In previous generations, the M5 has been powered by the 286bhp straight-six that started life in BMW’s M1 supercar, by a 340bhp evolution of the legendary six, then most recently by a 400bhp 5-litre V8 in the last 5 Series body shape. And now the M5 version of the controversially styled new 5 Series moves the super-saloon the goalposts again, with a 5-litre V10 engine that’s the most powerful BMW have ever put in a road car. Which means, if you push the right buttons, a peak of 507bhp, and 520Nm of torque – which is a full 25 per cent power hike over the last M5.

And this is a stunningly impressive engine. Like BMW’s F1 V10s it has a 90 degree vee-angle and compact dimensions for such a large capacity, so it sits usefully low in the nose for a lower centre of gravity. Like the racing engines it has sophisticated individual electronic control for each of the ten air-gulping throttle ‘butterflies’, for exceptional power and instantaneous responses.

It also has Bi-VANOS variable valve timing, to give the best possible spread of power with the best drivability, and it has the most powerful electronic engine management package so far created for a road car, with three 32-bit processors and the ability to perform more than 200 million individual calculations and instructions per second. All of which makes this a very special engine indeed...
...but you don’t need an engineering qualification to know that, you just have to listen to the new M5 take off in anger and you’ll get the point. Because the other thing the M5 V10 shares with a racing engine is its enthusiasm for high revs – and if that doesn’t means the screaming 19,000 or so of the F1 brigade, it does mean a heady 8250rpm redline which is way beyond the point where most road car engines would already have disintegrated, and BMW don’t hide it with excessive silencing, they let it howl through racing style manifolds and four huge tailpipes.


Multi-mode to suit…
Then they start to add the tricks. For reasons best known to themselves, but presumably to satisfy political sensitivity and the toughest emissions regulations, they give this mighty engine two power modes – a basic 400bhp, and at the simple touch of a button, that headline 507bhp, which is obviously the one that most people will be interested in.

And that’s the one that gives claimed performance figures of 0-62mph (0-100kph) in 4.7 seconds, which isn’t particularly unusual for a top-end super-saloon any more, or 0-124mph (0-200kph) in 15 seconds, which is pretty impressive punch in any company, especially with five seats!
But now we start to hit the complications, because the M5 doesn’t just have one character any more, it has the option, at the touch of a few buttons, of multiple personalities. First of all there’s that choice of power outputs, but what goes with that is also a choice of damper settings to vary the ride comfort and handling balance, a choice of how aggressively the traction and stability controls cut in (and even the option to switch the stability control out altogether when conditions permit), a choice of manual and automatic transmission modes, each with its own range of programmes to vary the shift time and responses, and most extreme of all, a ‘launch control’ function for ultimate take-offs.


The gears
The variable damping and stability controls are already reasonably familiar territory, and useful for different driving conditions, even different driver moods, and it’s hard to argue with them. The multi-choice transmission settings are a different matter, and arguably the new M5’s weakest link – or at least it’s least satisfying one.

Because the transmission in question is a new seven-speed version of BMW’s Sequential Manual Gearbox (SMG), which offers automatic shifts but isn’t an automatic and which has the positive action of a clutch but which doesn’t have the irritation of a clutch pedal. So in theory you get all the efficiency advantages of a manual gearbox with all the simple changes of an automatic – the big drawback being that even in this latest development, SMG still lacks one very important thing, refinement.

To put it crudely, the SMG is a bit of a thumper, and unless you make subtle throttle adjustments to help it on its way (which largely defeats the object of ‘automatic’ shifts) you feel and hear every gearchange, up or down, in a way that you’d probably be ashamed of if you were doing it yourself. And with this much power and seven gears it is a real issue. Which is clearly one reason for the next complication – six levels of shift-speed in ‘manual’, touch-shift mode, and five in full automatic mode. And that’s probably nine too many, rather than two that work smoothly.

Stand by for take-off...
Still, the marketing men insist that’s what the customer wants, choice, and the engineers have delivered – and then they’ve added that ultimate option, launch control. Which goes like this. Select full, 507bhp grunt via the one-touch ‘M Drive’ button on the wheel (which also optimises the damper and stability settings and turns the effective and clear head-up instrument display into a rev-counter and gearshift indicator. Now disable the Dynamic Stability Control, select the most aggressive of the ‘S’ shift programmes, hold the gearshift lever forwards, and floor the throttle.

The engine builds to optimum launch revs and stays there until you let go of the lever – and then the car catapults forwards with a chirp of tyres and a mighty howl of power while all you do is keep the pedal buried in the luxurious carpet. When the revs peak, it slams into the next gear and rides out the wheelspin, and then the same again, and again, and again – with barely describable violence, until it hits the M5’s voluntarily restricted 155mph (250kph) maximum, or in our case, an indicated 272kph (170mph), which the engineers put down to ‘tolerances’.

This is a very impressive feature, but it is also worryingly brutal, and you wonder what it’s for, because it’s also thoroughly anti-social and if you do it more than twice in succession you have to give the car time to recover and re-programme the whole thing all over again.

Verdict
Which in a nutshell is why the new M5, fast and fantastically musical as it is, isn’t quite as instantly appealing as the older, simpler generations. Beyond the power, the performance and the tricks, it also has a staggeringly good chassis set up for impeccaple handling and steering, and it has awesome brakes. But there are times, especially when the SMG transmission is making its own decisions, when you’d just prefer it to be that little bit simpler. Then it would be genuinely brilliant. As it is, it is brilliant but flawed, and sometimes that’s just frustrating.



Please click on an image below to see an enlarged photo:

[Ashok Arora]

"Racing style manifolds"

Can't wait to hear it up close....

[max_m5]

frustrating?

[keithw]

Well, this would appear to be the first negative review of the E60 M5. I assume it is unbiased. Could it be he couldn't master the SMGIII or some of the settings in such a short time and became frustrated?

Keith

[max_m5]

Originally Posted by keithw

Well, this would appear to be the first negative review of the E60 M5. I assume it is unbiased. Could it be he couldn't master the SMGIII or some of the settings in such a short time and became frustrated?

Keith

i hope so...

otherwise... it should be a daily driver

[desualt]

Mr. Laban must be very satisfied with his Dodge Caravan...


Robert

[vndkshn]

I suspect that just as with opinions of the overall design (interior and exterior), SMGIII will generate similar splits.

[M6 Forever]

We guessed it pretty much: the thorny issue will be SMG III. To be fair, I need to drive before getting carried away either side of the fence.

Interestingly, compared with the other review, this one says "...it has awesome brakes", whereas the other article in anohter thread was questioning the mere dual and single calipers.

[Will Harvey]

Nice review. The engine has received universal praise. I can't wait to experience it for myself. I also share some of the same frustrations you have mentioned. As I have been using M5's as my daily drivers for approx. 15 years, I really appreciate the subtle, understated styling. It is nice to travel as fast as possible without attracting any attention from the police or cell phone do-gooders. The previous M5's were recognized by only the most discerning eye. The e60 M5 is far from understated. The louvers in the front fenders are unnecessary, something I would expect on a Pontiac. SMG.. great technology, but don't want it on my everyday driver. idrive.. what does it do for me?? Oh, and a full size spare wheel and tire please! Will









QUOTE=tonach]First drive: New BMW M5
by Brian Laban, last updated September 14 2004

For twenty years since the first example appeared as a new breed of super-fast premium saloon, BMW have thought of the mighty M5 as their ‘businessman’s express’ – the up-market and practical face of high performance driving. And one of the things that always made the M5 particularly attractive to a certain kind of customer was that, for all its performance, it was relatively understated, and relatively uncomplicated – just plenty of power in a thoroughly developed but straightforward rear-drive chassis wrapped in a muscular, but really quite subtle, body.


The new, fourth generation M5 is still, unmistakably, the businessman’s express, but now it has a new edge, and a bit less of the old understatement. Because the new M5 is more aggressive than ever. Having been revealed in what turns out to be very close to production form at the Geneva Show in March this year, as the Concept M5, the real thing goes on sale in most of Europe in January, and in the UK a couple of months later ‘in Spring’, with a projected price of £61,755.

It will be a lot of fast, handsome car for the money, and in some ways a much more complex one than the M5 has ever been before – which is partly good news and partly less good news, depending on how subtly you like your ‘businessman’s express’ performance to be delivered.

Engine: Mind-boggling
In previous generations, the M5 has been powered by the 286bhp straight-six that started life in BMW’s M1 supercar, by a 340bhp evolution of the legendary six, then most recently by a 400bhp 5-litre V8 in the last 5 Series body shape. And now the M5 version of the controversially styled new 5 Series moves the super-saloon the goalposts again, with a 5-litre V10 engine that’s the most powerful BMW have ever put in a road car. Which means, if you push the right buttons, a peak of 507bhp, and 520Nm of torque – which is a full 25 per cent power hike over the last M5.

And this is a stunningly impressive engine. Like BMW’s F1 V10s it has a 90 degree vee-angle and compact dimensions for such a large capacity, so it sits usefully low in the nose for a lower centre of gravity. Like the racing engines it has sophisticated individual electronic control for each of the ten air-gulping throttle ‘butterflies’, for exceptional power and instantaneous responses.

It also has Bi-VANOS variable valve timing, to give the best possible spread of power with the best drivability, and it has the most powerful electronic engine management package so far created for a road car, with three 32-bit processors and the ability to perform more than 200 million individual calculations and instructions per second. All of which makes this a very special engine indeed...
...but you don’t need an engineering qualification to know that, you just have to listen to the new M5 take off in anger and you’ll get the point. Because the other thing the M5 V10 shares with a racing engine is its enthusiasm for high revs – and if that doesn’t means the screaming 19,000 or so of the F1 brigade, it does mean a heady 8250rpm redline which is way beyond the point where most road car engines would already have disintegrated, and BMW don’t hide it with excessive silencing, they let it howl through racing style manifolds and four huge tailpipes.


Multi-mode to suit…
Then they start to add the tricks. For reasons best known to themselves, but presumably to satisfy political sensitivity and the toughest emissions regulations, they give this mighty engine two power modes – a basic 400bhp, and at the simple touch of a button, that headline 507bhp, which is obviously the one that most people will be interested in.

And that’s the one that gives claimed performance figures of 0-62mph (0-100kph) in 4.7 seconds, which isn’t particularly unusual for a top-end super-saloon any more, or 0-124mph (0-200kph) in 15 seconds, which is pretty impressive punch in any company, especially with five seats!
But now we start to hit the complications, because the M5 doesn’t just have one character any more, it has the option, at the touch of a few buttons, of multiple personalities. First of all there’s that choice of power outputs, but what goes with that is also a choice of damper settings to vary the ride comfort and handling balance, a choice of how aggressively the traction and stability controls cut in (and even the option to switch the stability control out altogether when conditions permit), a choice of manual and automatic transmission modes, each with its own range of programmes to vary the shift time and responses, and most extreme of all, a ‘launch control’ function for ultimate take-offs.


The gears
The variable damping and stability controls are already reasonably familiar territory, and useful for different driving conditions, even different driver moods, and it’s hard to argue with them. The multi-choice transmission settings are a different matter, and arguably the new M5’s weakest link – or at least it’s least satisfying one.

Because the transmission in question is a new seven-speed version of BMW’s Sequential Manual Gearbox (SMG), which offers automatic shifts but isn’t an automatic and which has the positive action of a clutch but which doesn’t have the irritation of a clutch pedal. So in theory you get all the efficiency advantages of a manual gearbox with all the simple changes of an automatic – the big drawback being that even in this latest development, SMG still lacks one very important thing, refinement.

To put it crudely, the SMG is a bit of a thumper, and unless you make subtle throttle adjustments to help it on its way (which largely defeats the object of ‘automatic’ shifts) you feel and hear every gearchange, up or down, in a way that you’d probably be ashamed of if you were doing it yourself. And with this much power and seven gears it is a real issue. Which is clearly one reason for the next complication – six levels of shift-speed in ‘manual’, touch-shift mode, and five in full automatic mode. And that’s probably nine too many, rather than two that work smoothly.

Stand by for take-off...
Still, the marketing men insist that’s what the customer wants, choice, and the engineers have delivered – and then they’ve added that ultimate option, launch control. Which goes like this. Select full, 507bhp grunt via the one-touch ‘M Drive’ button on the wheel (which also optimises the damper and stability settings and turns the effective and clear head-up instrument display into a rev-counter and gearshift indicator. Now disable the Dynamic Stability Control, select the most aggressive of the ‘S’ shift programmes, hold the gearshift lever forwards, and floor the throttle.

The engine builds to optimum launch revs and stays there until you let go of the lever – and then the car catapults forwards with a chirp of tyres and a mighty howl of power while all you do is keep the pedal buried in the luxurious carpet. When the revs peak, it slams into the next gear and rides out the wheelspin, and then the same again, and again, and again – with barely describable violence, until it hits the M5’s voluntarily restricted 155mph (250kph) maximum, or in our case, an indicated 272kph (170mph), which the engineers put down to ‘tolerances’.

This is a very impressive feature, but it is also worryingly brutal, and you wonder what it’s for, because it’s also thoroughly anti-social and if you do it more than twice in succession you have to give the car time to recover and re-programme the whole thing all over again.

Verdict
Which in a nutshell is why the new M5, fast and fantastically musical as it is, isn’t quite as instantly appealing as the older, simpler generations. Beyond the power, the performance and the tricks, it also has a staggeringly good chassis set up for impeccaple handling and steering, and it has awesome brakes. But there are times, especially when the SMG transmission is making its own decisions, when you’d just prefer it to be that little bit simpler. Then it would be genuinely brilliant. As it is, it is brilliant but flawed, and sometimes that’s just frustrating.



Please click on an image below to see an enlarged photo:[/quote]

[MEnthusiast]

Im basically with Will, but gasp! I think if BMW ever built it with a stick shift I would give it a try because I think idrive is learnable and the styling is as good as the E60 can ever look and I can accept the M5 styling. But in the end, the sense of involvement I get comes from several things, one of which is doing my own shifting. So, BMW, are you listening? I hope so.

[Gustav]

I think I remember this reviewer. Could it be the very same review for the old British magazine "Performance Car" that tested a E34 M5 3,8 when it was new, the article name was "Laban on the Limit", as his last name. Im pretty sure it is.